The Open Door: On Immigration, Fear, and the American Conscience
We are a vast and wealthy nation.
Our land stretches from ocean to ocean, from tundra to tropics, abundant in food, fuel, intellect, and innovation. We are rich not only in money but in infrastructure, in institutions, in cultural heritage, in technological marvels. We speak of ourselves as a beacon of liberty, a promised land, a refuge of opportunity.
And yet — at the sound of footsteps at our southern border,
we tremble.
We are told to fear the migrant.
We are warned that our country is full.
That we are under siege.
That we are being replaced.
And so the gates close. The rhetoric hardens. The laws tighten.
And children sleep on concrete in detention centers.
What Are We So Afraid Of?
Not resource depletion — we waste more food than we distribute.
Not job loss — immigrants grow our economy, start businesses, take risks.
Not crime — immigrants are statistically less likely to commit it.
Not cultural decline — unless you believe culture must be static, preserved in amber rather than evolving with grace.
No — what we fear is change.
What we fear is difference.
What we fear is the mirror that immigration holds up to us.
For immigrants, more than anything, reveal our hypocrisy.
We speak of freedom and opportunity — and deny both.
We speak of Christian charity — and turn away families in need.
We speak of hard work — and then despise the hands that build our homes, clean our hospitals, pick our fruit.
The Myth of Burden
Immigrants are not a burden. They are the backbone.
They do not drain our wealth — they expand it.
They do not threaten our values — they remind us of them.
They do not dilute our culture — they enrich it.
Every major study confirms this. Economists have shown that immigration raises productivity. Demographers warn that without new arrivals, our population will age and shrink. Business leaders acknowledge that immigrants fuel innovation.
And yet we persist in the fantasy that welcoming others means losing something ourselves — as if decency were a zero-sum game.
Who Benefits From the Fear?
It is worth asking — who profits from the fear of immigration?
- Politicians benefit, especially those who traffic in nationalism and grievance. They distract the public from broken health systems, corporate greed, and environmental catastrophe by conjuring images of a caravan invasion.
- Media outlets benefit, especially those that monetize fear. Every headline screaming about “surges” or “waves” reinforces a story of scarcity.
- Corporations benefit — paradoxically — from the presence of undocumented workers, whose legal vulnerability makes them easier to exploit, harder to organize, and cheaper to pay.
And in all this, the ordinary citizen is asked to believe a lie:
That our neighbor is our rival.
That the poor man crossing the border is the cause of our troubles.
That solidarity is weakness.
The Moral Cost of the Closed Door
The cost of this fear is not just economic. It is spiritual.
A nation that refuses the stranger becomes a nation that forgets its own story.
Unless we are Native American, our ancestors came from elsewhere. Some came fleeing famine, others fleeing pogroms, war, poverty, or persecution. Some came in chains. All came with hope.
To deny that same hope to others is not self-preservation. It is moral amnesia.
And when we close the door, we don’t just shut out the world.
We shut out the best part of ourselves.
What Would a Just Nation Do?
A just nation would not confuse order with cruelty.
It would not pretend that a wall is a policy.
It would not weaponize legality to dehumanize.
A just nation would ask not “How do we keep them out?”
But “How can we welcome them well?”
It would recognize the migrant not as a threat, but as a fellow traveler in search of the same peace, the same dignity, the same chance that we once sought.
Conclusion: The Nation We Claim to Be
If we truly are the nation we claim to be —
A land of liberty.
A haven for the tired and poor.
A shining city on a hill —
Then the question is not whether we can afford to welcome others.
The question is whether we can afford not to.
For a nation’s greatness is not measured by its GDP, its armies, or its walls —
But by how it treats the stranger at the door.
No comments:
Post a Comment